StorageUnitsNear.me
Customer Trusted

The Best Storage Facilities in Shelter Island, New York

Top 3 storage facilities in Shelter Island, New York. Rated 4.4/5 stars based on our comprehensive facility evaluation system.

3
Top Facilities
4.4/5
Avg Rating
285
Total Reviews
21
Avg Years

Top Storage Facilities

Ranked by our comprehensive facility quality evaluation system

1

CubeSmart

CubeSmart

★★★★☆
4.4/5

CubeSmart in Riverhead is a highly-rated facility serving Shelter Island with advanced security features including gated access, 24/7 video surveillance, and individually alarmed units. The facility is known for its exceptional cleanliness, climate-controlled options, and excellent customer service. Customers frequently praise its convenient drive-up access and reliability for storing vehicles, boats, and household items.

Experience:19 years
Reviews:120 customer reviews
500 Old Country Road, Riverhead, NY 11901

Storage Services:

Climate-controlled storage24/7 accessvehicle and boat storage
2

Public Storage

Public Storage

★★★★☆
4.6/5

Public Storage in Greenport offers secure and well-maintained storage solutions with features like keypad entry, 24/7 surveillance, and on-site management. The facility is celebrated for its spotless units, responsive customer service, and additional amenities such as moving supplies and truck rentals. Its proximity to Shelter Island makes it a popular choice for residents seeking dependable storage.

Experience:25 years
Reviews:75 customer reviews
50 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944

Storage Services:

Self-storagepacking suppliestruck rental
3

Extra Space Storage

Extra Space Storage

★★★★☆
4.3/5

Extra Space Storage in Hampton Bays provides top-tier security with electronic gate access, video monitoring, and well-lit premises. The facility is highly regarded for its cleanliness, organized layout, and friendly staff. It offers a variety of unit sizes, including climate-controlled options, and is easily accessible for Shelter Island customers needing secure storage for personal or business items.

Experience:20 years
Reviews:90 customer reviews
100 Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays, NY 11946

Storage Services:

Drive-up storageclimate controlbusiness storage

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about storage units in Shelter Island, New York

What storage unit sizes are most commonly available on Shelter Island, NY, and what can they typically hold?

On Shelter Island, storage facilities typically offer units ranging from small 5x5 lockers to larger 10x20 spaces. A 5x5 unit is ideal for seasonal items like patio furniture or holiday decorations, while a 10x10 can accommodate the contents of a one-bedroom apartment. Given the island's seasonal population, medium-sized units (e.g., 10x10 or 10x15) are popular for storing belongings during off-season months.

Are climate-controlled storage units necessary on Shelter Island, NY, and what items require them?

Yes, climate control is highly recommended on Shelter Island due to the humid summers and cold, damp winters. This feature is essential for protecting sensitive items like wooden furniture, electronics, artwork, important documents, and fabrics from mold, warping, and corrosion. While standard units may suffice for robust items, the coastal environment makes climate control a wise investment for preserving valuables.

How do access hours work for storage facilities on Shelter Island, NY, especially considering ferry schedules?

Access hours on Shelter Island often accommodate the ferry schedules, with many facilities offering extended or 24/7 access via gate codes or keypads for tenants. It's crucial to confirm specific hours with the facility, as some may have reduced hours during off-season or holidays. Planning around ferry timetables is advisable, so inquire about access flexibility to ensure it meets your needs, especially if you're commuting from off-island.

What security features should I expect from a storage facility on Shelter Island, NY?

Reputable storage facilities on Shelter Island typically provide robust security including gated access with personalized codes, 24/7 video surveillance, well-lit premises, and individual unit alarms. Given the island's secluded nature, these measures help protect against unauthorized access and theft. Always ask about specific protocols, such as on-site management or regular security patrols, to ensure your belongings are safe.

Are short-term or month-to-month storage contracts available on Shelter Island, NY, for seasonal residents?

Yes, many storage facilities on Shelter Island cater to seasonal residents and offer flexible month-to-month leases without long-term commitments. This is ideal for summer visitors or winterizing boats and homes. Be sure to clarify any minimum rental periods or notice requirements for move-out, as policies can vary between facilities, allowing you to store items only when needed.

Storage Tips & Insights

Expert advice for storage solutions in Shelter Island, New York

Maximizing Your Space: A Guide to Storage Room Solutions on Shelter Island, NY

Living on Shelter Island, NY, offers a unique blend of coastal charm and tight-knit community living, but it also comes with its own set of space challenges. Whether you're in a historic cottage, a seasonal home, or a year-round residence, finding room for all your belongings can be tricky. That's where smart storage room solutions come into play. For Shelter Islanders, a well-organized storage room isn't just about stashing away off-season items—it's about creating a functional space that adapts to the island's seasonal rhythms and limited square footage.

Given Shelter Island's location and the logistical considerations of bringing items on and off the island, planning your storage room is key. Start by assessing what you truly need to store. Seasonal gear like boating equipment, fishing rods, and winter coats can quickly clutter a garage or basement. Consider installing sturdy, wall-mounted shelving or overhead racks to keep these items accessible yet out of the way. For delicate items prone to Long Island's humidity, such as family heirlooms or important documents, invest in airtight plastic bins with desiccant packs to prevent moisture damage. Labeling everything clearly will save you time, especially during busy summer months or holiday transitions.

If your home lacks built-in storage space, don't overlook creative options. Under-stair areas, attic eaves, or even a dedicated closet can be transformed into efficient storage rooms with modular shelving units. For bulkier items like patio furniture or kayaks, a local self-storage facility on Shelter Island or nearby in Suffolk County can be a lifesaver, offering secure, climate-controlled units that protect your possessions year-round. This is particularly valuable for seasonal residents who need to store belongings safely between visits.

Ultimately, a well-planned storage room on Shelter Island enhances your daily life by reducing clutter and stress. By tailoring your storage to the island's environment—prioritizing moisture control, maximizing vertical space, and considering off-site options when needed—you can enjoy a more organized, serene home. Whether you're decluttering for a renovation or simply making room for new memories, these practical steps ensure your storage works as hard as you do to maintain that peaceful island lifestyle.

Nearby Cities

Explore storage facilities in nearby cities

About Storage in Shelter Island, New York

Shelter Island residents and businesses deserve secure, convenient storage when choosing a facility. Our featured facilities specialize in self storage, climate controlled storage, and vehicle storage with flexible rental options in New York.

Local Expertise

Facilities familiar with Shelter Island community and local storage needs.

Secure Storage

Licensed and monitored facilities with proven security records in Shelter Island.

Convenient Service

Flexible access and dedicated support for customers and businesses.