StorageUnitsNear.me
Customer Trusted

The Best Storage Facilities in Fishers Island, New York

Top 3 storage facilities in Fishers Island, New York. Rated 4.4/5 stars based on our comprehensive facility evaluation system.

3
Top Facilities
4.4/5
Avg Rating
228
Total Reviews
17
Avg Years

Top Storage Facilities

Ranked by our comprehensive facility quality evaluation system

1

CubeSmart Self Storage

CubeSmart

★★★★☆
4.5/5

This highly-rated facility is a top choice for Fishers Island residents due to its proximity to the ferry terminal. It features robust security with electronic gate access, 24/7 video surveillance, and well-maintained, clean units. Customers praise its excellent customer service, convenient access hours, and variety of unit sizes. The facility is known for its reliability and serves as a key storage solution for seasonal and long-term needs.

Experience:16 years
Reviews:78 customer reviews
1 Shaw's Cove, New London, CT 06320

Storage Services:

Climate-controlled storage24/7 electronic accessmoving and packing supplies
2

StorageMart

StorageMart

★★★★☆
4.4/5

Located just off I-95, this facility is easily accessible for Fishers Island customers via the New London ferry. It offers state-of-the-art security including individually alarmed units, on-site management, and comprehensive surveillance. Reviews highlight its cleanliness, spacious drive-up access, and helpful staff. It is a trusted option for both personal and commercial storage needs in the region.

Experience:21 years
Reviews:65 customer reviews
500 Gold Star Highway, Groton, CT 06340

Storage Services:

Drive-up storageboat and RV storagebusiness storage solutions
3

Public Storage

Public Storage

★★★★☆
4.3/5

This facility is popular among Fishers Island residents for its secure, gated environment with 24/7 monitoring and climate-controlled options. It provides a range of unit sizes and is noted for its cleanliness and professional management. Customers appreciate the easy online services and convenient location near major routes, making it a reliable choice for storage in the area.

Experience:15 years
Reviews:85 customer reviews
100 Roosevelt Avenue, Mystic, CT 06355

Storage Services:

Vehicle storagepacking suppliesonline rental and bill pay

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about storage units in Fishers Island, New York

What storage unit sizes are most practical for residents of Fishers Island, NY?

Given the island's limited space and seasonal population fluctuations, 5x5, 5x10, and 10x10 units are among the most practical and commonly used sizes in Fishers Island. These accommodate seasonal items like patio furniture, boating gear, and off-season clothing. Larger units (10x15 or 10x20) are also available but may be in higher demand during the off-season transitions.

Are climate-controlled storage units necessary on Fishers Island, and are they available?

Yes, climate-controlled storage is highly recommended on Fishers Island due to the coastal climate with humidity, salt air, and temperature swings. These units protect sensitive items like electronics, documents, wooden furniture, and artwork from moisture and corrosion. While not all facilities may offer them, it's a sought-after feature, so inquire early about availability.

How does the ferry schedule impact access to storage facilities on Fishers Island?

Access to storage facilities is directly tied to the Fishers Island ferry schedule, especially for non-residents or those storing items seasonally. Most facilities align their access hours with ferry operating times, and some may offer extended or 24/7 access by prior arrangement. Always confirm access policies and plan visits around ferry departures to avoid being stranded.

What security features should I look for in a Fishers Island storage facility?

Prioritize facilities with gated access, individual unit alarms, 24/7 video surveillance, and well-lit premises. Given the island's remote location, these features help deter unauthorized access and provide peace of mind. Some facilities may also offer on-site management or resident managers for added security during off-hours.

Are short-term or month-to-month storage contracts available on Fishers Island for seasonal residents?

Yes, many storage facilities on Fishers Island cater to seasonal residents and offer flexible month-to-month leases or short-term contracts. This is ideal for summer visitors or winterizing boats and homes. Be sure to clarify any minimum rental periods or rate changes between peak and off-peak seasons before signing.

Nearby Cities

Explore storage facilities in nearby cities

About Storage in Fishers Island, New York

Fishers Island residents and businesses deserve secure, convenient storage when choosing a facility. Our featured facilities specialize in self storage, climate controlled storage, and vehicle storage with flexible rental options in New York.

Local Expertise

Facilities familiar with Fishers Island community and local storage needs.

Secure Storage

Licensed and monitored facilities with proven security records in Fishers Island.

Convenient Service

Flexible access and dedicated support for customers and businesses.